Youngstown / Columbus Edition
10-8 NEWS

"We follow an America‑first approach, prioritizing truth, community, and national values."

HEADQUARTERED IN COLUMBUS • SERVING 88 OHIO COUNTIES

Why the Justice Department Is Still Withholding Epstein Files: What Officials Say and What Critics Charge

November 16, 2026

Nearly a year after Congress passed a law ordering the government to make its Jeffrey Epstein records public, the Justice Department under President Donald Trump still has not released everything, and the dispute over what remains hidden is now being fought in federal court.

The Epstein Files Transparency Act passed in November 2025 with nearly unanimous support and was signed by President Trump. It gave the department 30 days to make public all unclassified records, documents, communications and investigative materials tied to Epstein, and it allowed only narrow redactions, mainly to protect victims. The department missed the December 19 deadline, released an initial batch, and then on January 30 published more than 3 million pages it described as its final release.

Critics say that is far from everything. Rep. Ro Khanna of California, a coauthor of the law, noted that the department identified about 6 million potentially responsive pages but released about 3.5 million. Reporting has since described roughly 2.5 million pages as withheld, with much of what was released heavily redacted.

What the Justice Department says. Officials argue they have followed the law. Todd Blanche, who leads the department, has said records were withheld to protect victims’ identities, to avoid jeopardizing ongoing investigations and because some material is child sexual abuse imagery that cannot legally be published. The department has also withheld documents it considers covered by attorney client privilege and attorney work product, along with duplicates. In a letter to Congress, the department said it withheld nothing because of embarrassment or political sensitivity and that members of Congress can review unredacted versions in person. Blanche has dismissed claims that the department is protecting powerful people, including the president.

What critics say. Khanna and Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky, the Republican coauthor, accuse the department of going beyond the exceptions the law allows. They point to a letter that the Justice Department released without redactions in 2024 and then released again this year with President Trump’s name blacked out. The department also missed the law’s deadline to give Congress a report explaining its redactions and listing government officials and politically exposed people named in the files. Some of Epstein’s victims have called the redactions excessive, and news organizations reported that summaries of FBI interviews containing uncorroborated allegations involving Trump appeared to be missing. Trump denies any wrongdoing, and the department said it was reviewing whether any records were improperly withheld and would publish any that were.

The court fight. Attorney and journalist Katie Phang sued the department in April. On June 25, U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan, an appointee of President Ronald Reagan, found the department had likely violated the transparency law and ordered it to unredact several files or explain why it could not. In its response, the department defended its redactions and asked for 60 more days to consider an appeal. A department filing acknowledged that some documents were withheld to shield internal deliberations, a reason the law does not explicitly allow. The department filed a notice of appeal on August 24 and has asked the federal appeals court in Washington to pause the judge’s orders, including one requiring a review of foreign language records, warning that once a document is released it cannot be taken back. Sullivan has warned that continued noncompliance could lead to contempt proceedings.

What comes next. The appeal is pending, and the new Congress that takes office in January will add pressure. Rep. Robert Garcia of California, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, has listed the administration’s handling of the Epstein investigation among his priorities. Whether the remaining files become public may ultimately be decided by the courts.

10-8 News will continue to follow the case and update readers as new records are released.

Sources